Chapter 5. Cases and other adpositional particles

Table of Contents

5.1. Instrumental
5.2. Relative
5.2.1. Genitive
5.2.2. Locative
5.2.3. Other cases
5.3. Genitive
5.4. Possessive
5.5. Ornative
5.6. Locative
5.7. Finalitive
5.8. Allative
5.9. Ablative
5.10. Illative
5.11. Sociative
5.12. Comitative

The place of the adpositions relative to the nominal head is not fixed in Denden and all adpositions can be used either as pre- or as postpositions.

Southern Colloquial Charyan has postpositions, while Northern Colloquial has prepositions, and whether the Denden adpositions are used prepositionally or postpositionally seems in some measure to be determined by the mother tongue of the speaker or author.

However, in the Denden as spoken in Broi, postpositionally used particles generally form a phonological unit with the head noun, while prepositionally used particles have a more independent status. It is interesting to note that Broian Denden is currently in a transitional phase, moving from an SVO to an SOV word order; it seems likely that the prepositional usage of particles is in part motivated by an analogy with verbal constructions, i.e. prepositionally placed particles can be interpreted as more verbal in nature.

Whether the postpositionally used case particles are in reality affixes or independent elements of the noun-phrase is a difficult question. As noted about, for instance, New Indo-Aryan (Masica 1991 : 212), “'...the line between such analytic elements and agglutinative affixes is uncertain...” The Denden case particles are in, what Masica (op. cit.), at Zograph's (1976) instigation, terms paradigmatic contrasts. The whole system of forming complex elements of noun phrases must be examined, especially when the analytical elements can just as well be analysed as suffixes, since they form, when one takes the stress patterns into account, a phonological unity with the head noun.

Adpositions often function as "case" particles (Blake 1994, 9-13), and we can distinguish between particles that indicate direct verbal arguments, such as the instrumental particle hye INST and the dative particle lye DAT (note that the core arguments, subject and direct object are not marked by any case particle), the particles indicating relationships beween nominals, such as the genitive oib GEN or the possessive lua POSS, and locative particles, such as the locative ar LOC or the inessive particle yo(murin) INESS.

The following table presents all case particles:

Table 5.1. Case Particles

Verbal Arguments
NameFormLabelGloss
InstrumentalhyeINSTwith
DativelyeDATto
Nominal Relationships
NameFormLabelGloss
GenitiveoibGENof
PossessiveluaPOSSof
ComparativeloghCOMPlike
RelativetanRTVn/a
Ornativedax ~ daxaORNn/a
SociativedandirSOCtogether
ComitativequatCOMwith
EnumerativeyENUand
PrivativetuPRIVwithout, lacking
Locational particles
NameFormLabelGloss
Location 
LocativearLOCat
Proximal Locativeyobal ~ yobarNLOCclose by
Interior 
Inessiveyo(murin)INESSin, inside
Exterior 
AdessivewauADESSat, close by, near
ExessivenilEXESSout, outside
Position 
Frontiveatal ~ atahlFRONTin front of
Postiveqe ~ ke ~ chePOSTbehind of
Intrativecanuin ~ canINTRAthrough, between
TegimentivetayrTEGaround, covering
Superessiveyülis ~ yülishSUPERon top of
SubessivenahaSUBESSunder
Source 
Partitivecu ~ zuPARTfrom (amongst)
ElativeoELAfrom (place)
AblativeobABLAout, out of
Destination 
IllativecaILLAinto, onto, inserting into
Augmented IllativecasheILLA2deeply into
AllativeyohalALLAtowards
FinalitivelyaGOALtowards
Path 
TranslativeswaranTRANSthrough
PerlativematanPERLA(being or going) alongside
TangentiveparTANGgoing along, while touching

5.1. Instrumental

hyeINST

The instrumental adposition hye INST marks an instrument distinct from the agent of the sentence. It can also indicate a cause or a comitative. However, the sociative particle dandir SOC is also used in a comitative sense, as is, of course, the comitative particle y COM. Causal clauses can be subordinated using the instrumental, but more often using the particle tan TAN.

The instrumental hye marks the instrument with which the agent of a sentence does something:

.   lananir.é hon   ka,  tau.layet, gerran mimir.ir   hye  layet.ju
    taste.PT1 after TOP  NEG.tasty  meat   pepper.DUP INST tasty.CRT
    If you've tasted [it], [and it] isn't tasty, you will certainly
    make the meat tasty with peppers.

.   seri  basuse seri  hye  ghijas!
    2sHGH wash   2sHGH INST shit
    You wash yourself with shit!
    
.   kaulon    Denyal tiran.ini davain hye  tyras.as e.da
    big_house Denyal catch.HAB birds  INST hand.DUP poss.3sMGH
    Denyal from the big house catches birds with his hands

.   koran hye  ka  yadir dox ga  lyan      ga
    veil  INST TOP woman all NOM beautiful NOM
    With a veil, every woman is beautiful
    
.   chaka.hau rai   semor e.dos      hye!
    beat.IMP  3pLGG knife poss.1pMGH INST
    Let's beat them up with our knives!
    

In this example, chaka 'to beat' is used, and not menar, to cut, to indicate that this is a proper fight, not a knifing from behind.

.   soi  hye  sümzi ka, tan dasir  hod'shulas ga, daha.
    wine INST drunk TOP TAN 3pfMGH head.mist  NOM tomorrow 
    They're drunk with wine, they'll have a misty head, tomorrow.

Due to the composite nature of Denden, there is great freedom in constructions. The following examples were taken from Hinadanzi's native grammar:

.   garal.al garalbay hye  hyahya
    hair.DUP brush    INST brush

    garal.al hye garalbay hyahya
    hye garalbay garal.al hyahya
    garalbay hye garal.al hyahya
    
    the hair is brushed with a brush
.   Yai   hye  e.do       leham teshit.é yo   maile,
    2sLGH INST poss.1sMGH money buy.PT1  that shirt

    yo   maile e.do       ga!
    that shirt poss.1sMGH NOM
    
    You've bought that shirt with my money, it's my shirt!

Causative constructions with hye are rare, and the usage is almost completely confined to the southern parts of Charya.

.   dabbe ca   qiri.ri e.do       penresh hye  tau.qireze.za
    paint into eye,DUP poss.1sMGH spatter INST NEG.see.EXP
    Because the paint spattered into my eyes I couldn't see.

.   ram   kisen.onai hye  zipaisan hye  sero  dotyuan.
    money steal.PERF INST army     INST 1sHGH poor
    Because the army stole [my] money, I've become poor.

Related to the causative usage of hye INST is the figurative usage which indicates which factor made a situation possible:

.    canoran seras daxa ga  hye serir kaulon ca  nahan tau.yindad
     key     1sHGH ORN  NOM INS 1pHGH house  ILL go    NEG.able_to
     Because he had the key on him we couldn't enter the house.

The comitative usage of hye INST is purely coordinative, and never indicates enumeration:

.    sero  hakaq.aq  hye  Hamal, Hamal qendor, sero  qendor, 
     1sHGH fight.HAB INST Hamal  Hamal win     1sHGH win

     tarna turantos tau.qendor.zi.
     but   nobody   NEG.win.AUG
     
     I regularly fight a bout with Hamal, Hamal wins, I win,
     but nobody ever wins out.

.    Manud yo   adan tau.adan ga! da    yumir'beru hye  qenan,
     Manud that man  NEG.man  NOM 3sMGH wife.first INST make_love

     xong.zi,  xong.zi   na da    yumir'verai hye  qenan
     tired.AUG tired.AUG so 3sMGH wife.second INST make_love

     tau.yindad. E.da       yumir.ir dilogh qenan!
     NEG.can     poss.3sMGH wife.DUP REFL   make_love
     
     That man Manud, he isn't a man! If he makes love with his first
     wife he's very tired, he's so tired he can't make love with his
     second wife. His wives must make love amongst themselves!